I agree, looking at the pic its clear that the middle three feathers are a hair shorter than the rest.  Super jake, maybe, but I would say jake based on that.  What was the beard and spur length?  Just curious.  I killed a mature bird the next to last Sat. in 2002 that weighed a whopping 13lbs 12ozs., had a 9" beard and little 3/4" spurs.  I kept the tailfan and when compared to other mature birds, it was more the size of a mature hens.  I took it as he was just the runt of the litter, and maybe he did some breeding and burned off a few pounds as the season progressed but he was not big by any means.