OldGobbler

OG Gear Store
Sum Toy
Dave Smith
Wood Haven
North Mountain Gear
North Mountain Gear
turkeys for tomorrow

News:

registration is free , easy and welcomed !!!

Main Menu

South Dakota Merriams

Started by WW, February 20, 2015, 11:19:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

WW

This is going to be the first year that I've hunted Merriams. I've always hunted easterns. Headed to Wyoming and SD in May.. What can I expect different about the Merriams vs the eastern? I've heard that it will be windy and they're used to it.. Also heard that you can call a LOT and it won't matter. What do you fellas say?

hobbes

It isn't always windy, unless you're hunting plains birds.  However, my interpretation of "windy" may have changed since I moved west.  On most days there is more wind than back home in IL.  I'm assuming you're hunting the Hills.  I've not hunted the Hills but would expect some wind.  I've seen some strong winds in Rapid City while traveling through and WY is known for wind but more so in the open plains.

As far as Merriam's go, in general they are considered easy compared to Easterns.  However, I think if you hunt public land pressured Merriam's enough you'll find that they can be as stubborn as an Eastern.  I believe some of the "easy" title comes from Eastern hunters making one trip to hunt unpressured heavily populated ranches or reservations.  For the most part Merriam's do not see as much hunting pressure as their Eastern cousins.
The toughest thing about Merriam's is they are constantly on the move, here one day and gone the next.

They do like to gobble.  I believe most of them have looser lips than an Eastern.  I call a lot to most Merriam's and don't normally have to be as subtle as a lot of Easterns require, but I have had to sweet talk a few of them in or go silent to entice a hung up bird in.

I don't know if it is their nomadic nature or the big country they live in, but they seem willing to come a long way to the call, and they can do it in a hurry.  Their weak sounding gobble may convince you they are farther than they really are.  The combination can result in bumped birds.

All of these generalities can be blown out of the water by that one bird just like those tough Easterns that have eluded you for days only to suddenly turn into a bird with a death wish.

crappieangler

I've only hunted merriams over 3 springs so take this for what it's worth, but they seem to stay henned up all season.  Not all of them, I've seen some break away from the group, but they don't seem to come in to calls or decoys as well as easterns where I've hunted.  Every year we'll get 1 or 2 Toms from decoying, but 2/3% of our successful hunts have been getting in their travel routes or spotting and stalking.  But when you do have a taker, they can come from a long, long way to get to you.   

As for calling, it hasn't seemed to matter much either way for me. I've had days where they talk all day like you've probably read about. But last year our first morning we didn't hear a single gobble off the roost or during the day until that evening.  In my opinion, on average they talk the same amount as all other subspecies.

Jim K

I agree you need to get in front of them for best success. I think they gobble more than the eastern I'm used to hunting. The fun part is, the hens are very vocal and I enjoy that. I've made four trips west to hunt them and I wish I could go every year. The Black Hills are fantastic. The amount of game is unreal there.

Timmer

I agree with a few comments - They seem more nomadic, but that could be differences in terrain than what I'm used to with easterns.  They are more vocal, but definitely not as loud.
Timmer

All of the tools, some of the skills!

crappieangler

I agree they're more nomadic and less loud, but sound carries through the mountains more. On the roost they will sound loud when you get a few sounding off at the same time in a big group.

Turkeyman11

Cover a lot of ground!  Especially in the morning and evenings.  Don't be shy about making one gobble on the roost.  Finding those Merriams  I believe is the biggest challenge.  There is a lot of country for them to be in and they seem to always be on the move.  Just because you hear a bird on a ridge today doesn't necessarily mean he'll be there tomorrow.  Also, I think the hunting gets better as the season goes.  The weather gets better, the breeding hens are disappearing to lay, and most of all hunters go home.  Cover some country and you will find birds.