OldGobbler

OG Gear Store
Sum Toy
Dave Smith
Wood Haven
North Mountain Gear
Gooserbat Game Calls
North Mountain Gear
turkeys for tomorrow

News:

only use regular PayPal to provide purchase protection

Main Menu

Top States for Non Residents?

Started by joey46, April 23, 2023, 01:28:22 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Kylongspur88

Quote from: Marc on April 26, 2023, 02:40:51 PM
Quote from: ScottTaulbee on April 26, 2023, 01:42:42 PM
Quote from: Kylongspur88 on April 26, 2023, 01:15:34 PM
Quote from: ScottTaulbee on April 25, 2023, 10:14:52 AM
I'm almost certain it has to be KY. I'm not sure where these guys got their info but every piece of public land within 150 miles of where I'm at has looked like a circus daily and the plates have been more colors than the rainbow.

This. It's been unbelievable this year. The locals aren't thrilled.
Between WMA tracts and National forest I found 1 pull off that didn't have a vehicle in it and hunted it.

Typically we get a couple, as in less than 5 at these places. This year there were 25 out of state trucks at 3 pull offs on 3 tracts of the same WMA during that opening day drive. And the tracts combined total less than 700 acres.  Not considering the 4 on another 120 acres. Or the ones on National forest.

Because turkeys do not migrate...  Most turkey hunters are in our own little bubble.  When we have good local hunting, and read about the decline of turkeys in neighboring states we think "those poor saps," and go on about our business of hunting.

Turns out that many turkey hunters are pretty passionate about turkey hunting, and a lot of them will travel to hunt if hunting locally is no longer a viable option.

Conservation issues and hunting access issues of one state will quickly trickle down to other states.  For those of you with good local turkey hunting currently, would you give up on the sport if that local hunting was no longer viable, or would you travel to hunt?

While I do believe that locals should have priority...  At some point the state will look for where the largest revenue streams are coming from...  Higher license fees, hotels, food, etc...  Are the locals putting in more financially than OOS hunters?  If not, where is the incentive for the state to reduce OOS hunting license sales?

Hunting waterfowl is my primary passion, I am used to contributing to non-local conservation (as waterfowl are migratory).

But as it turns out, I think it would benefit turkey hunters to look at conservation funding a bit less centrally, and start thinking a bit more globally as well.

I've got no issues with people traveling to hunt but when hordes of people rush into a particular area with decent numbers and kill high volumes of birds in that particular area pretty soon those areas will also hold poor numbers just like the areas where people may be traveling from. The absolute number one predator of mature toms are hunters. I'm not willing to give up hunting but I'm more than willing to pay for draws and quotas where states are attempting to control pressure [Nebraska] or even limit  bag limits [Ohio] to ensure I can continue to hunt. With respect to oos license sales, I can tell you turkeys aren't our money maker. Deer are. But at what point does the department look at it's current model and say is this sustainable? Are we attempting to generate some revenue even if detrimental to wildlife populations? and/or alienating their own residents? Like stated above I'm also going to get in my local commissioners ear and offer some suggestions. If he doesn't want to hear I'll keep going up the ladder until I get to someone who does

ScottTaulbee

Quote from: Kylongspur88 on April 26, 2023, 03:12:38 PM
Quote from: Marc on April 26, 2023, 02:40:51 PM
Quote from: ScottTaulbee on April 26, 2023, 01:42:42 PM
Quote from: Kylongspur88 on April 26, 2023, 01:15:34 PM
Quote from: ScottTaulbee on April 25, 2023, 10:14:52 AM
I'm almost certain it has to be KY. I'm not sure where these guys got their info but every piece of public land within 150 miles of where I'm at has looked like a circus daily and the plates have been more colors than the rainbow.

This. It's been unbelievable this year. The locals aren't thrilled.
Between WMA tracts and National forest I found 1 pull off that didn't have a vehicle in it and hunted it.

Typically we get a couple, as in less than 5 at these places. This year there were 25 out of state trucks at 3 pull offs on 3 tracts of the same WMA during that opening day drive. And the tracts combined total less than 700 acres.  Not considering the 4 on another 120 acres. Or the ones on National forest.

Because turkeys do not migrate...  Most turkey hunters are in our own little bubble.  When we have good local hunting, and read about the decline of turkeys in neighboring states we think "those poor saps," and go on about our business of hunting.

Turns out that many turkey hunters are pretty passionate about turkey hunting, and a lot of them will travel to hunt if hunting locally is no longer a viable option.

Conservation issues and hunting access issues of one state will quickly trickle down to other states.  For those of you with good local turkey hunting currently, would you give up on the sport if that local hunting was no longer viable, or would you travel to hunt?

While I do believe that locals should have priority...  At some point the state will look for where the largest revenue streams are coming from...  Higher license fees, hotels, food, etc...  Are the locals putting in more financially than OOS hunters?  If not, where is the incentive for the state to reduce OOS hunting license sales?

Hunting waterfowl is my primary passion, I am used to contributing to non-local conservation (as waterfowl are migratory).

But as it turns out, I think it would benefit turkey hunters to look at conservation funding a bit less centrally, and start thinking a bit more globally as well.

I've got no issues with people traveling to hunt but when hordes of people rush into a particular area with decent numbers and kill high volumes of birds in that particular area pretty soon those areas will also hold poor numbers just like the areas where people may be traveling from. The absolute number one predator of mature toms are hunters. I'm not willing to give up hunting but I'm more than willing to pay for draws and quotas where states are attempting to control pressure [Nebraska] or even limit  bag limits [Ohio] to ensure I can continue to hunt. With respect to oos license sales, I can tell you turkeys aren't our money maker. Deer are. But at what point does the department look at it's current model and say is this sustainable? Are we attempting to generate some revenue even if detrimental to wildlife populations? and/or alienating their own residents? Like stated above I'm also going to get in my local commissioners ear and offer some suggestions. If he doesn't want to hear I'll keep going up the ladder until I get to someone who does
I'd suggest speaking to all of them. Not just your local man. Brian Fisher is really great. Ralph swallows will act like he cares and will text or email you to set up a time to chat and then will never actually have that time. The rest, in my experience, won't even answer a email or call. As you stated above, I have no problem with people traveling and have held some really great tailgate conversations with OOS guys. My problem is the ones that act like the duck hunting crowd does. Example, you get to the gate 2 hours before day light, not legal shooting time, you ease in to the area that you plan on hunting, you know where a bird is roosted and you're within 120 yards of him in the dark. You sit there, no light, in the dark, waiting on go time. 10 minutes before shooting time you hear gravel popping down where your truck is parked, here comes 3 head lamps coming right your way. They are 100 yards from you now, you whistle and they continue your way. They are now 60 yards from you, you flash your head lamp at them. They continue your way, and come over to you. You tell them that your truck is the one parked at the pull off and that you're hunting this particular patch of woods in front of you, they say ok and continue past you in to the woods your facing and procedé to blow the gobbler off the roost, then seconds after the turkey flies off, the proceed to lay in to crow calls and owl hooters in such a way that would make the Grand Nationals proud. So you leave, obviously infuriated, and see that they were from a bordering state.

That's a real example and has happened far too often the past couple of years.  Absolutely no respect. Just "I drove here to hunt and by god I'm going to hunt right here so get out of the way".


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

deerhunt1988

Ya'll be sure to click those like and subscribe buttons!

deadbuck

To answer the poster above me who asked if turkey hunting gets crappy in my local area will I travel out of state or quit hunting. I will just quit turkey hunting.

bigriverbum

Quote from: deadbuck on May 01, 2023, 11:39:27 AM
To answer the poster above me who asked if turkey hunting gets crappy in my local area will I travel out of state or quit hunting. I will just quit turkey hunting.

i will too. plenty of other hobbies and passions to fill the void as much as it would hurt to quit. and i live 20 minutes from 2 other states. 

lol- "turkeys don't migrate. so lets all converge on the few places that still have them and kill all those too" 

some of ya'll like killing, not hunting

ScottTaulbee

lol- "turkeys don't migrate. so lets all converge on the few places that still have them and kill all those too" 

some of ya'll like killing, not hunting
[/quote]



Bingo, there's the real answer.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

richard black

I agree totally Scott. Why kill more than one just because the law, or rules, or whatever says you can. I remember when there were no turkeys to hunt and it looks like we're headed back slowly but surely.

WV Flopper

 Joey, it is sad. I agree.

For one guy that tags out there are two tag holders that get nothing. But.....the guys that kill a turkey are supposed to move on with one.

That's what alot of these guys think. When I go OOS and have two tags I intend to fill both. Good for you if you don't, that is your choice. I choose to fill mine if possible.

Lots of these guys should stick to regulating their selves.

Blackduck

Hard for me to believe the people preaching these restrictions are very good(meaning successful) turkey hunters.

Want to restrict everyone to one bird on public, you have my support. Keep your hands off my private tags. You can't touch those birds anyway, and they're doing just fine.  :thanks:

Bedge7767

Jim

Marc

I do understand that Alaska has very little turkey hunting pressure. ;D
Did I do that?

Fly fishermen are born honest, but they get over it.