I see on some of the hunting shows they are using just a turkey tail to bring in toms. Has anyone tried this on pressured birds? I don't know if this is even legal in Michigan.
Really really bad idea. Don't do it
Quote from: rosharb on March 26, 2015, 02:43:21 PM
I see on some of the hunting shows they are using just a turkey tail to bring in toms. Has anyone tried this on pressured birds? I don't know if this is even legal in Michigan.
Pressured birds most of the time means public land. Its up to you if you feel comfortable but IMHO I wouldn't even try it (not even on private land). Whatever you decide, please be safe and good luck
IMO public land usually means pressured birds and more hunters. I only have access to public land so this happens to be the case where I hunt. In the past I thought about using a turkey tail, but considering the amount of hunting pressure where I hunt I thought it might not be the safest idea. If it was private land and I was the only individual hunting it, I might think differently. Good Luck this season.
Quote from: Bowguy on March 26, 2015, 03:35:48 PM
Really really bad idea. Don't do it
This sums it up.
:TrainWreck1: Trouble waiting to happen :z-twocents:
While it obviously works as seen on various TV hunting shows, it presents a safety issue especially on public ground which several have already pointed out. Why not just carry a gobbler or jake decoy and situate the fan at the rear of your decoy? You could even run some clear fishing line to the tail to give it some action. I've done this in the past and sometimes, like everything else, it works. For me, it seems that having something visual is a motivation for the gobbler to come on in after my calling has gotten him close enough to see the decoy(s).
While it obviously works as seen on various TV hunting shows, it presents a safety issue especially on public ground which several have already pointed out. Why not just carry a gobbler or jake decoy and situate the fan at the rear of your decoy? You could even run some clear fishing line to the tail to give it some action. I've done this in the past and sometimes, like everything else, it works. For me, it seems that having something visual is a motivation for the gobbler to come on in after my calling has gotten him close enough to see the decoy(s).
One of my good buddies does it every year on his own property with great success and I've always wanted to do it cause he says it's crazy how they will just charge him and get 10 yd away. But that is on his own private land, as far as public wouldn't do it at all!!!!! Heard of plenty of people just getting shot cause they heard a turkey gobble, so you if your in private where you know nobody is gonna mess with ya go for. If not don't!
Done it with great success on private land, wouldn't consider it on public ground.
Might work, you might get shot.
Open fields private land only.
Wouldn't carry a fan anywhere close to public or decoys for that matter
I do it and have great success. I hunt private land. wouldn't reccomend on public. This technique has been out for years a lot of people had never heard of it and now that it's on tv everybody gonna start doing it and there won't be any gobblers left.????
I've heard it works great, but other hunters scare me. Seems like every year someone in this state gets shot, sometimes killed. Guy in my county was shot a few years ago while hunting private land. A trespasser shot through brush at his calls. He lived, but had his face, chest and arms ate up with shot.
I've used a fan tied to a stake with fishing line. Never had it close to me but would put it among my decoys. Seemed the fan, even without a body attached to it would draw them in...As for tolling or whatever you'd like to call it...Ahhhh, I get a shiver just thinking about it! Can you imagine the conversation at your viewing? "He did WHAT???!!!"
My two cents :z-twocents: worth, I woudn't do it on public land, asking to get shot, too many yahoos. I look at turkey hunting as a challenge in doing it as simple as I can get. Get the bird coming in with calling and choice of set-up. I don't knock anyone for using any legal means but there is something to be said to use a saying, the KISS Principle: keep it simple stupid, and by stupid I'll start with me, and don't miss watching the tom coming in hunting for a hen but finding you!