Does anyone else count birds that they call up and someone else shoots as a kill? I personally always have because I could have shot it just as easily. I am just wondering what others think.
No cuz then I would have to count all their misses too!!!
If it doesn't go against my bag limit I didn't kill it.
I don't count it as a kill, but I do take the same amount of pride in it. If my decisions and work are what result in the kill, then I was successful in my mind.
Dont count in my book thats another mans kill not mine.
I don't but I also don't keep track of my own kills either....
No ... but I do enjoy calling them in!
negative ghostrider.....
If I don't kill it, it ain't my kill.
I agree with everyone else. If i didn't shoot it, I'm not counting it as my kill. Plus, who's to say that I wouldn't have missed him?
I don't count it as a kill but I do feel the caller and the person who planned the setup have done the majority of the work. Theres more to being a good hunter in my opinion then having killed a large number of turkeys.
I don't.
I take pride in fooling another wary longbeard, but no I do not count the kill.
Great fun but...no
I don't take credit for it but I do greatly enjoy it. Plus it means I still have a tag or two to keep hunting
Quote from: guesswho on April 08, 2014, 04:34:39 PM
If it doesn't go against my bag limit I didn't kill it.
gotta pull the trigger to count
I keep a record of it on my log, but do not count it as a kill.
I also keep record of my misses
I don't and won't. I keep a record of mine by notching my tags. I have no idea how many turkeys have died in front of me.
Yes, and so does every serious turkey hunter that I know. We only get 3 tags here and even going to another state for another 2 tags, 5 tags ain't much for a 5 week season. So u take kids, wives, friends, neighbors, coworkers, etc, get new people into the sport, and count all the birds u bring in and "watch die". That way u and your turkey buddies can have a friendly competition to see who calls the most in. You keep track of the misses too. I guess that for the guys that don't get out enough to go double digits in a season then there wouldn't be a lot of point to it. I don't keep a running career total of birds called in and killed, only of my personal birds(counting beards/tags), but we all keep up with birds called in year to year. I am surprised no one else on here does.
Quote from: Blackduck on April 08, 2014, 09:34:09 PM
Yes, and so does every serious turkey hunter that I know. We only get 3 tags here and even going to another state for another 2 tags, 5 tags ain't much for a 5 week season. So u take kids, wives, friends, neighbors, coworkers, etc, get new people into the sport, and count all the birds u bring in and "watch die". That way u and your turkey buddies can have a friendly competition to see who calls the most in. You keep track of the misses too. I guess that for the guys that don't get out enough to go double digits in a season then there wouldn't be a lot of point to it. I don't keep a running career total of birds called in and killed, only of my personal birds(counting beards/tags), but we all keep up with birds called in year to year. I am surprised no one else on here does.
I think most of us know how many we kill and how many we guide.
For a lot of guys here, that's way into double digits and the bottom line is serious turkey hunters don't count a guided bird towards their own personal kill totals. The OP's original question pertained to that.
I don't really keep up with the number of kills I have, no one that matters to me really cares. However many I have killed will never be enough. The most important one is the next one.
I've seen a few turkeys die and can pretty much tell a story of every one I've seen breath his last breath but I couldn't tell you a number (never added them up) I like watching turkeys get fooled weather I'm the one pulling the trigger or not. So to answer your question, No, if I don't pull the trigger than it's not my statistic but who really gives a rip? The only number that matters to me is the (6) that got away(missed). I've killed more than some and not near as many as others but I have a brain full of turkey hunting memories that my kids usually never hear the same one twice.
I don't count it as one of mine, but I write the successful hunts of others in my hunting journal. I've hunted with quite a few people and have held many of them get their first birds, so I want to have something to help me keep the memories.
Love to call them in for others, but only track & record my own kills...
mudhen
I do. If I take a guy to my place, find the gobbler, show him where and how to set up, do all the calling, make all the critical decisions on when to call, when to stay put, when to move, whisper exactly what to do as the gobbler gets in range--and all he does is pull the trigger??? That gobbler is exponentially more a product of my expertise and efforts than his.
I don't count kills,I lost track at one. ;D I love getting the assist, especially for the 1st timer.
I only count my kills. I agree that 90% of the birds I call in for others I would have been able to kill and most of the time they are just the trigger man. If I were to count those it would be twice as many as I have killed.
Joe
I do not know the total # of turkeys I've killed or by others with me. I do know total # called into gun range last year and how many shot oppourtunities and # killed and missed. Kinda keep track by property too but don't keep a log or anything.
I journal all the hunts whether I am on the gun/bow or someone else is. It includes birds taken, birds missed, and birds that should have been taken and never shot at and generally everything else going on during the hunt. Not really hung up on numbers at all, but when I have having a "bad" season, I sometimes look back and see how blessed I have been with all the years of amazing hunts.
Quote from: Terry on April 08, 2014, 04:34:40 PM
I don't count it as a kill, but I do take the same amount of pride in it. If my decisions and work are what result in the kill, then I was successful in my mind.
:agreed:
Not I said the Gooserbat.
I keep a log of all my kills and the ones I help call up. I dont count them as kills though. I put the persons name and the normale stuff, date, time, specs of turkey.
No log, no counting for me. But honestly, squeezing the trigger is the easy part. I take great pride in calling a bird in to range and love to retell that story as much as one where I squeeze the trigger. If I can't eat it, it ain't my kill. I wish duck tasted like turkey, cause I would never share another one. Or redfish. But I will share my trout and ducks.